Persons with conventionally treated insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) appear to be impaired in their ability to reduce fed-state urea production appropriately in response to dietary protein restriction (Hoffer LJ, Taveroff A, and Schiffrin A. Am J Physiol 272: E59-E67, 1997). To determine whether these conclusions apply to whole body sulfur amino acid (SAA) catabolism, we used samples from this protocol to measure daily urinary sulfate excretion and fed-state sulfate production after a high-protein test meal before and after dietary protein restriction. Eight normal subjects and six IDDM subjects treated with twice-daily intermediate- and short-acting insulin consumed a mixed test meal containing 0.50 g protein/kg after adaptation to 4 days of high protein intake (1.28 g protein/kg body wt) and again after 5 days of dietary protein restriction (0.044 g/kg). Adaptation to protein restriction decreased daily urinary sulfate and urea-N excretion by ~80%. Over the first 24 h of protein restriction, urinary sulfate excretion decreased more than urea-N excretion for both the normal and IDDM subjects. Under conditions of a high prior protein intake, fed-state sulfate production was normal for the IDDM subjects; protein restriction reduced fed-state sulfate production by 51% (normal subjects) and 59% (IDDM subjects; not significant). We conclude that whole body SAA metabolism is normal in conventionally treated IDDM before and after dietary protein restriction. SAA catabolism, as measured by fed-state sulfate production, may be a convenient and useful method to determine the extent of whole body protein dysregulation in IDDM.